We raised $8.5m for AI agents
First Rate Movers

How First Rate Movers swapped profit-sharing spreadsheets for a portal the whole crew can see

Brian Tustin

With Brian Tustin, Owner at First Rate Movers

The First Rate Movers crew walking in front of their trucks
Industry
Moving
Region
Millsboro, DE
Size
50–100 employees
Plan
Profit sharing

At a glance

First Rate Movers is a family-owned moving company Brian Tustin bought in December 2022. He brought a hospitality background and one belief: when the crew works hard for customers, the crew should share in the result.

Brian spent years in hospitality before he bought First Rate Movers, and he knows what good service is worth. When a crew pulls off a hectic cross-state move, he wants them to earn more than their hourly pay.

“Moving sucks and it's hard work. That's why people hire movers. I want the guys to win. They deserve to win.”
— Brian Tustin, Owner

The spreadsheet grew with the business

For 18 months Brian ran bonuses and profit sharing by hand. Each payout had to account for jobs worked, customer reviews, and hours, and hours moved week to week with the job count. The spreadsheet kept growing, and he couldn't show it to the crew.

“I'm not going to share my whole spreadsheet with every crew member or every employee. Security and privacy reasons.”
— Brian Tustin, Owner

A portal for every crew member

ShareWillow turned the spreadsheet into a structured profit-sharing plan. Each crew member logs in to a private portal and sees their own earnings and how the plan pays out, without seeing anyone else's numbers.

“When the team has their ShareWillow portal that they can log into, it makes it a really beautiful experience for everyone involved.”
— Brian Tustin, Owner

Brian also wanted advice on the plan itself. ShareWillow works with many owners who share profits, so he could see how other businesses split them.

“It was an opportunity to activate an expert and learn how other industries and other owners distribute profits, to make sure we're doing it appropriately and fairly.”
— Brian Tustin, Owner

The results

  • No more spreadsheets to calculate payouts.
  • Every crew member sees their own earnings in a private portal.
  • Jobs worked, customer reviews, and hours all feed one plan.
  • The ShareWillow team stayed hands-on through setup.
“Anytime you have the opportunity to bring people behind the fold and create some transparency, communicate the mission, vision, purpose, and tie cash or compensation to that based on performance, it just feels like such a no-brainer.”
— Brian Tustin, Owner

Put the number in every tech's pocket.

Book a free call. We'll pull your numbers, show you what a performance pay plan would pay each tech, and what it would do to your average ticket and callbacks.

  • See a custom plan built from your data
  • Learn what hundreds of service businesses pay their top techs
  • One-on-one with a plan specialist
Book a demo

ShareWillow has designed and implemented performance pay and incentive plans for hundreds of service businesses.

Chris McDowell
Chris McDowell
Business Operations Manager · Clogbusters
“I would 100% encourage people to do performance pay, and definitely partner with ShareWillow.”